Quick answer: California law (10 CCR §2695.8(g)) allows an insurer to specify an aftermarket crash part only if that part is at least equal to the original part in kind, quality, safety, fit, and performance, and the insurer must warrant that in writing in its own estimate. We check every part an insurer specifies against that standard, we document what we find, and if a specified part proves unequal on your car, the law requires the insurer to pay to return it and replace it with a compliant or original part.
Get a free estimate or
book a 15-minute appointment, or call or text
408-935-0210.
OEM, aftermarket, and used: what the words mean
OEM parts are made by or for your car's manufacturer, the same parts the car was built with. Aftermarket parts are copies made by other companies; quality ranges from certified parts that genuinely match the original to parts that do not fit, do not carry the same corrosion protection, and do not behave the same in a second crash. Used and recycled parts are original parts taken from another vehicle. Every part on a Crown estimate and invoice is identified as one of these, because California law requires it and because you deserve to know what is on your car.
What California actually requires
Some shops will tell you that being under factory warranty entitles you to OEM parts. That is not the law, and we will not tell you things that are not true. Here is what the law does say, and it is stronger than the slogan:
- An insurer may not require a non-OEM crash part unless it is at least equal to the original in kind, quality, safety, fit, and performance.
- The insurer warrants that equality in writing, in the estimate it prepares. If the warranty language is missing, we ask for it.
- The insurer pays for any modifications needed to make a specified part work.
- If the insurer learns a part is not equal, it must stop specifying it.
- On your specific car, if a specified part is not equal, the insurer pays the cost of returning it and of removing and replacing it with a compliant part or an OEM part.
How we handle it on your repair
- We mark every non-OEM part on the insurer's estimate before work starts, so nothing slides in unnoticed.
- We attach the manufacturer's position statement and repair procedures for structural parts, safety systems, sensors, and one-time-use hardware. For those parts there is usually no aftermarket part that can meet the equal standard at all.
- We fit and document. If a specified part is tried and found unequal, you get photos and measurements, not opinions, and the supplement cites the regulation.
- You decide with real information. Where an aftermarket part genuinely meets the standard (a certified part on an older car, for example), we will tell you so. Where you want OEM regardless, you may pay the price difference, and that choice is written on your estimate so there is never a surprise.
- Leased cars: most lease agreements require OEM parts. Bring us the lease and we will put that clause in the file, where it belongs.
Why this matters beyond the repair bill
Parts decide how your car protects you in the next accident, whether its driver-assistance systems read the road correctly, and what the car is worth when you sell it. Insurers specify aftermarket parts to save money, which is their job. Holding them to California's equal standard is ours. Our full parts position goes out with every insurance estimate we write, so the standard is set before the first part is ordered.